By Nick Godt
With government spending seen replacing consumer outlays for the
foreseeable future, some investors trying to anticipate an eventual
economic recovery are turning to infrastructure and materials
stocks instead of the usual early-cycle plays.
"As the consumer continues to retrench, this wouldn't be a
typical recovery [...] where you see gains in early cyclicals such
as housing, retail and auto stocks," said Owen Fitzpatrick, head of
U.S. equities at Deutsche Bank.
"The market has gravitated towards some growth sectors that are
linked to infrastructure, such as the industrials, materials and
energy," he said. Technology stocks also seem to have been a
beneficiary, he noted.
So far this year, technology is the best performing sector of
the S&P 500 index, rising 6.3%. That's followed by defensive
sectors, such as healthcare and utilities, both up 2.9%, and the
energy sector, up 2.1%.
Materials, meanwhile, are one of the "least-bad" performing
sectors, falling 0.3%. That sector includes the shares of mining,
construction, and chemicals firms.
As for the consumer discretionary sector, which includes
retailers, homebuilders and auto manufacturers, it is down 6.2%
year to date.
On Monday, the market was little changed as details on a bank
rescue plan and a vote on the passage of the $780 billion economic
stimulus package were both postponed until Tuesday.
The Dow Jones Industrial Average was down 60 points at 8,219.
The S&P 500 index was up 5 points at 863, while the Nasdaq
Composite fell 11 points to 1,579.
Homebuilder Beazer Homes USA , a consumer discretionary stock,
jumped more than 20% after it reported a narrower quarterly loss.
But its fellow homebuilder Lennar fell after Citigroup cut its
rating on the stock.
The S&P homebuilder ETF (XHB) was down 1%. It's little
changed year-to-date, after sliding more than 50% last year.
By comparison, shares of U.S. Steel Corp. rose more than 6%
after it said 500 employees have taken voluntary early retirement.
And the iShares S&P global infrastructure ETF , which first
slumped 10% through January, has gained more than 7% since February
started.
Different this time
Stocks tend to try and anticipate eventual economic recoveries
from six to nine months ahead of time. And consumer discretionary
stocks have tended to lead those pre-recovery efforts, said Jack
Ablin, chief investment officer at Harris Private Bank.
"That's been the pattern," he said. "There's certainly been this
traditional boost from the early cyclicals that may not be around
this time because the cycle has changed."
Since the 1980s, bear markets and economic downturns in the U.S.
have been addressed mainly by monetary policy. The Federal Reserve
would cut interest rates to levels low enough that consumers and
businesses would eventually start borrowing and spending again.
But this time around, the credit crisis has brought lending,
along with consumer and corporate spending, to a grinding halt. And
although the Fed has already slashed interest rates to near zero,
few are expecting the economy to recover without government
spending.
Outside of the U.S., hundreds of billions of dollars in stimulus
plans have also been announced around the world, notably in China
and the European Union.
Besides infrastructure stocks, analysts have noted a recent
rebound in some commodities and metals as signaling that the market
may be starting to price in some eventual economic recovery.
"There is rotation from the more conservative stocks [...], the
foods and more defensive names," said Paul Nolte, director of
investments at Hinsdale Associates, in a note. "The rotation is
going into the basic materials, technology and the industrial
sector which all saw large gains last week."
Whether the market might be getting ahead of itself or not,
anticipation of better times ahead has thus far benefited these
sectors over those directly linked to consumer spending.
That might eventually change if the market starts betting that
the stimulus package will work, and boost employment and spending,
according to Hugh Johnson, chairman of Johnson Illington
Advisors.
But such evidence might take a long while to really emerge. By
turning to sectors that might benefit directly from government
spending, be they growth oriented or not, the market might be
playing it fairly safe for a while, says Harris' Ablin.
"In our view, the market probably won't start smelling the roses
until the second half of the year," he said.