There are about 1,500 high-tech companies in the Ottawa area
alone, and about 30% of them can trace their roots to Nortel
Networks Corp. (NT), according to Doyletech Corp.
"It's a grim day in Canada," said Glenn McDougall, managing
partner at Doyletech, a technology research firm based in
Ottawa.
Nortel, which less than 10 years ago comprised more than
one-third of the value of the S&P/TSX Composite Index, said
Wednesday it's seeking protection from creditors in Canada and the
U.S.
The networking-equipment firm is a shadow of its former self,
but still spends about C$1 billion annually on research and
development and serves as an incubator for some of Canada's top
technology minds. If it disappears completely, or if a foreign
buyer moves the firm's research and development laboratories out of
Canada, the result could be a massive brain drain, analysts
said.
"The benefits (of Nortel) to Canada aren't just that C$1 billion
(in annual R&D spending)," said Lawrence Surtees, an analyst at
IDC Canada. "It acts, in effect, as an employment engine for highly
trained, high-tech graduates from Canadian universities. If it were
to no longer be here, or have labs here, that to me would be the
greatest blow from a bankruptcy."
Nortel alumni have for decades gone on to create successful
Canadian high-tech companies, and that value-creation process is
now at risk, analysts said.
Surtees noted that Terence Matthews and Michael Cowpland, two of
Canada's best-known high-tech entrepeneurs, met while working for
Nortel. Cowpland went on to form Corel Corp. (CREL), a software
company that once went head-to-head with Microsft Corp. (MSFT) in
the word-processing sector. Matthews founded several successful
communications companies, including Newbridge Networks Corp., which
was acquired by Alcatel, and Mitel Corp.
Doyletech has compiled a massive family tree that lists
companies that can trace their roots back to Nortel's research arm,
originally known as Bell Northern Research. Among the publicly
traded companies on the list are: Tundra Semiconductor Corp.
(TUN.T), Zarlink Semiconductor Inc. (ZARLF), March Networks Corp.
(MN.T), Mosaid Technologies Inc. (MSD.T), Dragonwave Inc. (DWI.T)
and JDS Uniphase Corp. (JDSU).
Talent Available To Other Cdn Tech Companies
While the disappearance of Nortel could spark an exodus of
talent from Canada, it would also provide Canadian companies with a
large talent pool from which to draw.
"If (Nortel) goes away, a lot of people in technology will be
looking for things to do," Mitel Chief Executive, Donald Smith,
told Dow Jones.
In addition, the disappearance of Nortel would mean Mitel and
other communications companies would have one fewer formidable
competitor to worry about, Smith said.
Nevertheless, Smith added that he takes no pleasure from
Nortel's plight. A former Nortel employee himself on two occasions,
Smith said he learned a lot working there and counts many current
Nortel employees as neighbors and friends. "Nobody can look at
(Nortel's bankruptcy filing) and take any joy in it," he said.
While Nortel is in dire straits, the company will continue to
operate, at least in the near term, said Duncan Stewart, director
of research at DSAM Consulting, a technology research firm in
Toronto. Indeed, under bankruptcy protection, Nortel will no longer
be under pressure from creditors to cut costs, meaning it may be
able to spend more on research and development, he said.
Stewart also suggested that the Canadian government may look to
step in and bail out Nortel in hopes of saving Canadian jobs.
In a statement Wednesday, Canada's Minister of Industry, Tony
Clement, said the government of Canada "appreciates the importance
of the telecommunications industry to our economy and will continue
to work with Nortel during its restructuring through Export
Development Canada."
EDC agreed Wednesday to provide up to C$30 million in short-term
financing through its existing bonding facility and is open to
discussing with Nortel post-filing financing in conjunction with
other financial institutions, Clement said in the statement.
Company Web Site: http://www.nortel.com
-Stuart Weinberg, Dow Jones Newswires; 416-306-2026;
stuart.weinberg@dowjones.com
TALK BACK: We invite readers to send us comments on this or
other financial news topics. Please email us at
TalkbackAmericas@dowjones.com. Readers should include their full
names, work or home addresses and telephone numbers for
verification purposes. We reserve the right to edit and publish
your comments along with your name; we reserve the right not to
publish reader comments.
Click here to go to Dow Jones NewsPlus, a web front
page of today's most important business and market news, analysis
and commentary. You can use this link on the day this article is
published and the following day.