Napster Concludes Dissident Candidates Unqualified for Board Seats
August 29 2008 - 8:32AM
Business Wire
Napster Inc�s (NASDAQ:NAPS) directors today mailed stockholders a
letter underscoring that the three dissident board candidates are
unqualified, and urged the re-election of experienced, independent
directors Richard J. Boyko, Philip J. Holthouse and Robert Rodin.
In the letter, Napster directors noted that: The dissident group
has provided no evidence showing that any of its members have ever
served on the board of a public company, meaning they would require
on-the-job training. The work experiences they describe in their
SEC filing--including musician, assisted living executive and ice
cream franchisee--are irrelevant to a company in the highly
competitive digital music business. The dissidents have selectively
misrepresented facts and distorted statements. The dissidents have
offered no specific business plan, other than suggesting a vague
review of Napster�s business, and have not shown they can
contribute to enhancing stockholder value. The dissidents have no
significant ownership in Napster and, in fact, have been frequent
sellers of Napster stock. To elect the most highly qualified,
independent directors, stockholders should immediately sign, date
and mail the WHITE proxy card they receive and discard any blue
proxy card. The complete text of the board of directors� letter to
stockholders is below. Napster�s annual stockholder meeting will be
held at 10 a.m. on Sept. 18 at the company�s headquarters at 9044
Melrose Ave., Los Angeles, Calif., 90069. About Napster Napster,
the pioneer of digital music, offers the ultimate in interactive
music experiences, creating better ways to discover, share, acquire
and enjoy music � anytime, anywhere. The company�s offerings
include �Napster� (www.Napster.com) � the most popular, on-demand
music subscription service in the world and the largest, most
comprehensive MP3 download store on the market; �Freenapster�
(www.freenapster.com), a unique Web experience offering free,
on-demand music legally in the U.S.; and �Napster Mobile,� one of
the industry�s fastest growing mobile music platforms, providing
the premier mobile music experience for customers in 11 global
markets. Headquartered in Los Angeles, Napster's services are
available in markets across the Americas, Europe and Japan.
Copyright (C) 2008 Napster, LLC. All rights reserved. Napster,
Napster Mobile, Napster To Go and Napster Light are either
trademarks or registered trademarks of Napster, Inc. or its
subsidiaries in the United States and/or other countries. All other
trademarks are owned by their respective owners. IMPORTANT NOTICE
FROM YOUR BOARD OF DIRECTORS August 29, 2008 Dear Fellow
Stockholder: At Napster, Inc.�s September 18, 2008 Annual Meeting
of Stockholders, you will be asked to make a critical decision
regarding the future of Napster. You and your fellow stockholders
will be electing three directors to serve for a three-year term on
the Napster Board of Directors. As you may know, three dissident
stockholders with no significant ownership in your company and who,
in fact, have recently been frequent sellers of shares proposed
that they be elected in lieu of the three experienced members
nominated for re-election by your Board. The proxy materials filed
by the dissident group with the Securities and Exchange Commission
make abundantly clear that all three are unqualified to serve on
the board of a publicly-traded company. Their SEC filings describe
work experiences�musician, nursing home executive, ice cream
franchisee, middle management banking executive and other
positions�that are irrelevant to a company like Napster competing
in the highly sophisticated digital music industry. In addition,
not one of the three nominees provided evidence they have ever
served on the board of a public company. Finally, the dissident
group�s proxy materials put forth no substantive plan for how its
nominees will enhance value for our stockholders if elected to the
Board, suggesting only a vague review of our business. Accordingly,
we strongly believe that the dissident group�s initiation of this
proxy contest is unnecessarily costly, disruptive to the company,
and not in the best interests of our stockholders. Your Board of
Directors unanimously recommends that you vote your shares FOR the
Board�s director nominees -- Messrs. Richard J. Boyko, Philip J.
Holthouse and Robert Rodin -- by signing, dating and returning the
enclosed WHITE proxy card today. We urge you to immediately discard
and not return any blue proxy card you may receive from the
dissident group. CONTRARY TO THE DISSIDENT GROUP�S ASSERTION, YOUR
BOARD IS FIRMLY COMMITTED TO ENHANCING VALUE FOR ALL NAPSTER
STOCKHOLDERS The press release recently filed by the dissident
group appears to imply that your Board is not willing to consider a
sale of the company. This is not true. Your Board has been, and
will continue to be, committed to enhancing value for all Napster
stockholders. Each of your Board�s nominees, like the rest of your
Board, is open to all opportunities for building value for our
stockholders by objectively evaluating all options for maximizing
your investment in Napster, including by exploring possible
strategic alternatives. To that end, Napster has retained UBS
Investment Bank to assist the company with that process, and UBS
has been actively advising the company with regard to possible
strategic alternatives. UNLIKE THE DISSIDENT GROUP, YOUR BOARD�S
NOMINEES ARE EXPERIENCED, HIGHLY QUALIFIED AND REQUIRE NO
ON-THE-JOB TRAINING Each of the Board�s director nominees has
demonstrated exceptional qualifications in representing our
stockholders and, collectively, in bringing a valuable and
broad-based set of business experience that will continue to serve
the long-term interests of our stockholders. Richard J. Boyko has a
deep background in advertising and marketing, having served in
senior executive creative positions at Ogilvy & Mather, one of
the nation�s most distinguished advertising agencies, for more than
twelve years, including as co-president and chief creative officer
from 1997 to 2003. Mr. Boyko is currently the Director of the VCU
Brandcenter the School of Mass Communications graduate program in
advertising. Mr. Boyko has been a member of our Board since April
2001 and has been a member of the board of directors of Martha
Stewart Living Omnimedia since June 2004. Philip J. Holthouse has
an extensive financial and accounting background, currently serving
as a partner with Holthouse Carlin & Van Trigt LLP, a certified
public accounting firm that has been honored as one of Public
Accounting Report�s Top 100 accounting firms in the nation. Mr.
Holthouse also holds a master�s degree in business taxation and a
bachelor�s degree in business administration from the University of
Southern California, a law degree from Loyola Law School in Los
Angeles and is a certified public accountant. Mr. Holthouse has
been a member of our Board since January 2004. Robert Rodin has
exceptional operational and management experience, serving more
than 25 years in senior management positions for various companies.
He is the founder and currently the chief executive officer of the
RDN Group, a management consulting firm. Prior to that, from April
1994 to October 1999, Mr. Rodin served as the president and chief
executive officer of Marshall Industries, a New York Stock Exchange
listed company that had more than $1.7 billion in annual sales at
the time of its acquisition by Avnet. Mr. Rodin is the author of
the book, �Free, Perfect and Now,� which chronicles his
transformation of Marshall Industries into a pioneer of emerging
web technologies and e-commerce platforms. Mr. Rodin has been a
member of our Board since January 2005, a member of the board of
directors of SM&A since January 2005, a member of the board of
directors of Inter-tel, Incorporated from March 2006 until August
2007 and a member of the board of directors of Marshall Industries
from October 1992 until October 1999. As detailed above, our
Board�s director nominees combined have more than 34 years of
relevant experience serving on public company boards, while the
dissident group�s director nominees have 0 years of experience
serving on public company boards. Further, the dissident group has
offered no proof of any management, operational or other experience
in the digital music industry. While we appreciate that the
dissidents are music enthusiasts and subscribe to Napster�s
service, such interests hardly qualify any of them to serve on your
Board. It is not in the best interest of Napster�s stockholders to
elect three unproven candidates who will require on-the-job
training to serve as directors of a public company. This is
especially the case where, as here, the nominees are unable to
offer any evidence that they can contribute to enhancing
stockholder value if they are elected to our Board. THE DISSIDENT
GROUP HAS SELECTIVELY MISREPRESENTED FACTS AND DISTORTED STATEMENTS
The dissident group has made assertions that we believe are
misleading in an attempt to gain support for its director nominees.
These misleading assertions only reinforce your Board�s
determination that the dissident group�s director nominees are the
wrong choices for your Board. #1: The dissident group implies that
your Board recently implemented a classified board structure
requiring a nearly impossible 80% vote of the outstanding shares in
order to change the bylaws allowing for the annual election of all
directors to further its own and management�s deep entrenchment and
control over the company. FACT: This is not true. First, the
classified board structure has been a part of Napster�s certificate
of incorporation (and bylaws) since Napster became a public company
in May 2001. This provision was not recently implemented by your
Board. Second, in this year�s proxy materials, your Board has
recommended a proposal to our stockholders to amend Napster�s
certificate of incorporation to eliminate the classified board
provision. The dissident group�s misleading assertions directly
conflict with these recent actions by your Board. #2: The dissident
group alleges that your Board recently implemented a change in
control severance package, commonly referred to as a golden
parachute for the Chairman/CEO. FACT: This is simply not true.
While we recently amended the employment agreement for our
Chairman/CEO in advance of the pending expiration of the initial
term of his agreement, no changes were made to the so-called golden
parachute provision, which has been a part of his employment
agreement since it was originally entered into in August 2003, and
is customary in our view for public company chief executive
officers. #3: The dissident group implies that your Board recently
adopted a �poison pill� stockholder rights plan. FACT: This
accusation also is just not true. In fact, Napster�s stockholder
rights plan has been in place since May 2001. In addition, your
Board believes that the stockholder rights plan serves to enhance
stockholder value in the event of an unsolicited takeover attempt
by giving your Board bargaining power and time to consider other
alternatives and negotiate a superior offer. YOUR VOTE IS IMPORTANT
-- SUPPORT YOUR BOARD NOMINEES SIGN, DATE AND RETURN THE WHITE
PROXY CARD TODAY DISCARD ANY BLUE CARD YOU RECEIVE The dissident
group�s nominees have no relevant experience in the digital music
industry, have no public company board experience and the dissident
group has not put forth any substantive plan for how their nominees
will enhance value for our stockholders if elected to the Board.
The dissident�s proxy materials also include selective and
distorted statements, which further draw into question the
suitability of the dissident group�s nominees to serve as your
directors. For those reasons, your Board of Directors unanimously
recommends that you vote your shares FOR the Board�s director
nominees -- Messrs. Richard J. Boyko, Philip J. Holthouse and
Robert Rodin -- by signing, dating and returning the enclosed WHITE
proxy card today. We urge you to immediately discard and not return
any blue proxy card you may receive from the dissident group. We
thank you for your support. Sincerely, THE NAPSTER, INC. BOARD OF
DIRECTORS Vernon E. Altman Richard J. Boyko Wm. Christopher Gorog
Philip J. Holthouse Joseph C. Kaczorowski Ross Levinsohn Brian C.
Mulligan Robert Rodin IMPORTANT 1. Your Board of Directors
unanimously recommends that you vote your shares FOR the Board�s
director nominees. Your Board has not endorsed any of the dissident
group�s director nominees or proposals. 2. Regardless of how many
shares you own, your vote is very important. Please sign, date and
return the enclosed WHITE proxy card. Please sign, date and return
each WHITE proxy card you receive in order to ensure that all of
your shares, including shares held in separate accounts, are voted
at the meeting. Only your latest dated proxy counts. 3. We urge you
NOT to sign any blue proxy card sent to you by the dissident group.
4. If you have sent a blue proxy card to the dissident group, you
have every right to submit a new proxy card to change your vote.
You may revoke that proxy and vote as recommended by Napster�s
Board of Directors by signing, dating and returning the enclosed
WHITE proxy card in the postage-paid envelope provided. If you have
any questions about voting or need additional assistance, please
contact Laurel Hill Advisory Group, LLC the firm assisting us in
the solicitation of proxies, toll free at 1-888-742-1305. Important
Information. On July 29, 2008, Napster, Inc. filed a definitive
proxy statement with the Securities and Exchange Commission (the
�SEC�) in connection with Napster�s 2008 Annual Meeting of
Stockholders. Napster�s stockholders are strongly advised to read
the definitive proxy statement carefully before making any voting
or investment decision because the definitive proxy statement
contains important information. Napster�s proxy statement and any
other materials filed by Napster with the SEC can be obtained free
of charge at the SEC�s website at www.sec.gov or from Napster at
http://investor.napster.com. Napster�s definitive proxy statement
and other materials will also be available by writing to Napster,
Inc., 9044 Melrose Avenue, Los Angeles, CA 90069 or by contacting
our proxy solicitor, Laurel Hill Advisory Group, LLC by toll-free
telephone at 1-888-742-1305.
Napster (NASDAQ:NAPS)
Historical Stock Chart
From Oct 2024 to Nov 2024
Napster (NASDAQ:NAPS)
Historical Stock Chart
From Nov 2023 to Nov 2024