POWER POINTS: US Nuclear-Power Projects Court New Partners
June 10 2009 - 4:55PM
Dow Jones News
U.S. nuclear-power developers are increasingly looking for new
partners to share the massive costs and risks of building new
reactors.
Some companies already have inked agreements, while others
including Progress Energy Inc. (PGN), NRG Energy Inc. (NRG) and
Duke Energy Corp. (DUK) are looking. Utilities and
nuclear-technology companies are the most likely partners for
projects, but industrial companies and sovereign wealth funds also
may take ownership stakes.
Driving the interest in partnerships is the sheer size of a
nuclear project. Duke estimates the cost of its proposed
two-reactor plant in South Carolina at $11 billion, plus financing
costs. Signing up partners also can assure that the massive amounts
of electricity a new reactor would generate has customers to use
it.
The need for partnerships rises from the fractured nature of the
U.S. power industry, which is spread out over dozens of generation
and utility companies. Some companies are looking at reactor costs
that rival their market capitalization unless they find a
partner.
"That almost requires these kinds of alliances," said James
Connaughton, executive vice president of corporate affairs and
public and environmental policy at Constellation Energy Group Inc.
(CEG).
Even as developers entertain possible partnerships, it remains
unclear how many plants actually will be built. The U.S. Nuclear
Regulatory Commission expects nearly two dozen project
applications, while climate change legislation advancing in
Congress would limit greenhouse-gas emission, providing a boost to
the nuclear power industry. Nuclear plants, unlike coal and natural
gas-fired plants, are nearly emissions free. But high costs and
lingering safety concerns have plagued new nuclear projects, with
no new reactors coming online in the U.S. in two decades.
Possible Partnerships; Companies Search
The form partnerships take depends on the project. Plants built
by utilities in regulated states likely will team up with other
investor-owned utilities, electric cooperatives and state and
municipal utilities, said Dan Krueger, managing director of the
generation and energy markets practice at consultancy Accenture
Ltd. (ACN).
These types of arrangements already are being seen, with Scana
Corp. (SCG) set to share ownership of its proposed plant in South
Carolina with state-owned utility Santee Cooper. Similar agreements
are in place at existing nuclear plants.
In deregulated states where power is sold at market prices, the
ownership of new reactors could include nuclear-technology
companies, large industrial companies that may have power-purchase
agreements with a new nuclear plant or sovereign wealth funds,
Krueger said.
Partnerships are being formed for plant construction as well.
Nuclear-technology companies and contractors share the risks
associated with costs and timing with developers, but aren't
owners. One such consortium is UniStar Nuclear, which is made up of
Constellation Energy, Electricite de France SA (EDF.FR), and
technology and construction companies.
Several companies are currently looking at new partnerships.
Progress Energy said it's in talks with possible partners for a
nuclear plant it has proposed in Florida. NRG Energy said it's
looking for equity investors for two reactors it's planning at an
existing nuclear plant in Texas. One potential arrangement the
company has discussed is partnering with another power company with
which NRG would then develop additional reactor projects.
Duke executives said during a recent meeting with analysts that
the company is looking at a range of partnership options. This
could include partnering on a project besides its own nuclear
project in South Carolina.
"We think partnering is the right thing to do, whether it is
partnering in something we build, or something that someone else is
building," said David Hauser, Duke's chief financial officer,
during the meeting last week.
Analysts have speculated Duke may be interested in investing in
the Scana project. Duke declined to comment, while a spokesman for
Scana said the company isn't looking for additional partners since
its utility and Santee Cooper will need all of the power the
reactors generate to meet customer demand.
(Mark Peters covers power, coal and emissions, and can be
reached at 201-938-4604 or mark.peters@dowjones.com.)
(TALK BACK: We invite readers to send us comments on this or
other financial news topics. Please email us at
TalkbackAmericas@dowjones.com. Readers should include their full
names, work or home addresses and telephone numbers for
verification purposes. We reserve the right to edit and publish
your comments along with your name; we reserve the right not to
publish reader comments.)