Western Foreshadows Poor 2Q Earnings For Refining Sector
June 02 2009 - 4:07PM
Dow Jones News
Western Refining Inc.'s (WNR) early prediction of a poor second
quarter signals a rough conclusion to first half of the year for
most oil refiners.
This quarter independent refiners have been hit with low
margins, the increasing cost of crude oil, and a contraction in a
trading benefit known as contango, which in the first quarter
helped the sector bring in profits. On top of that Western has
burdensome interest payments and has decreased production at its El
Paso, Texas refinery while it undergoes maintenance.
In a federal filing Monday, Western estimated that its
second-quarter operating income will range from $5 million to $25
million. For the second quarter of 2008, Western reported a net
income of $8.2 million, a 94% decreased compared with the same
period in 2007.
"Even if Western were to come in at the top end of its guidance,
we would still expect a loss," Credit Suisse analyst Mark Flannery
wrote in a note to clients Tuesday. "We believe that there is
growing evidence that weak realized margins are not confined only
to Western."
Margins, however, can be volatile. Caris & Co. analyst Ann
Kohler said margins were poor in April and have improved in May. In
the last week of May, refining margins averaged about $10.63 a
barrel of crude, compared with the last week of April when margins
were at $9.94 a barrel.
"We still have a month left to go so we can't completely write
things off," Kohler said. "I'm not expecting anyone else to have a
loss... (but) consensus estimates for the group is too high."
The group includes Holly Corp. (HOC), Frontier Oil Corp. (FTO),
Valero Energy Corp. (VLO), Sunoco Inc. (SUN) and Tesoro Corp.
(TSO).
Western's early forecast was prompted by its offering Monday of
14 million common shares, $100 million of convertible senior notes
and $600 million of senior secured notes.
The El Paso-based company was forced to offer debt and equity
because it could not sell its Yorktown, Va., refinery to pay off
existing debt covenants, Kohler said.
"They really need to escape the clutches of those covenants,"
Kohler said. "Their inability to sell their assets really forced
them into this mode."
The company put the 63,000 barrel-a-day refinery on the block
last year but has been unable to find a buyer in the economic
downturn. Part of the company's existing debt covenants relate to
the acquisition of this refinery and two others from Giant
Industries in 2007. In addition to the El Paso and Yorktown plants,
Western operates two refineries in New Mexico.
Western was just one of three independent refiners taking on
debt in the last 24 hours; Holly and Tesoro both announced
offerings of senior unsecured notes.
The debt raising was a way for the companies to cover future
capital expenditures, Chi Chow, an analyst with Tristone Capital
Co. in Denver, wrote in a note to clients.
Chow said the debt will help Tesoro deal with the rising cost of
crude and the weak margins - part of what is pressuring most of the
sector this quarter.
-By Susan Daker, Dow Jones Newswires; (713) 547-9208;
susan.daker@dowjones.com