Apple iPhone Still Looking For Place In China
June 12 2009 - 9:30AM
Dow Jones News
Apple Inc.'s (AAPL) popular iPhone, a runaway hit in the U.S.
and Europe, has encountered headwinds in emerging economies like
China that are expected to provide the next leg of growth for the
company's iconic smartphone.
In India, where cell phones are often the first device a family
buys, only 50,000 iPhones have sold since the local unit of
Vodafone Group Plc. (VOD) and Bharti Airtel Ltd. (532454.BY) began
offering the smartphone in August 2008. In Russia, where the iPhone
went on sale last year, Apple's three partners had each expected to
sell millions of handsets; as of May, roughly 400,000 had been
sold.
More importantly, the Cupertino, Calif.-based consumer
electronics giant has had difficulty penetrating China, the biggest
developing market. Apple's efforts to bring the iPhone to the
world's most populous country have stalled amid lengthy discussions
with China Mobile Ltd. (0941.HK) and China Unicom Ltd. (0762.HK),
two of the country's top cell phone operators.
Holding the iPhone back: A combination of high prices and
lengthy service contracts. In India, a basic iPhone cost about
$340, roughly a third of annual per capita income, putting it out
of reach for many people. Consumers in India and China, as well as
other developing countries, often balk at signing lengthy
contracts, preferring pre-paid plans that Apple and its partners
have avoided.
Apple's difficulty grabbing a bigger piece of the cell phone
market in developing economies comes as the company leans on the
iPhone for an increasingly larger portion of annual revenue that's
expected to reach $35 billion this year. In Apple's recently ended
second quarter, about 18% of its $8.1 billion in revenue came from
iPhone sales, more than from desktop computer sales or the iTunes
store.
The iPhone has helped fuel a more than 60% jump in Apple's
shares. On Thursday, Apple shares slipped 0.2% to $139.95.
Apple declined comment for this story.
Few countries hold as much potential for Apple as China, where a
fast-growing urban middle class has propelled cell phone and
computer sales. Apple Chief Operating Officer Tim Cook recently
said the company hoped to enter the market next year.
Cracking China, however, will be tough.
Chinese consumers are unlikely to pay a premium for Apple
products, where its brand doesn't hold the cachet it does in
countries like the U.S. and Japan. Apple's iPod music player
accounts for less than 8% of the Chinese market for media players;
its Macintosh line of personal computers, less than 1% of the
computer market.
A host of regulatory and cultural issues also bode poorly for
the iPhone's China prospects. Chinese telephone regulators require
the phone's Wi-Fi function - a key feature - to be turned off.
Of course, the iPhone will likely find an audience in China if
it hits the market. Though it isn't sold via legitimate channels,
an estimated one million iPhones already circulate on the Chinese
black market, according to various estimates.
Still, reaching a mass market in China might be difficult. A key
iPhone attribute, downloadable music and videos from iTunes, is
unavailable in China. Apple doesn't have a Chinese version of its
iTunes store, in part because music labels are concerned about the
potential for intellectual property abuses.
And without a local partner, like China Mobile or China Unicom,
Apple might find it difficult to reach the audience it needs. That
effort is made all the more difficult because of Apple's resistance
to compromising with its partners.
"If the Chinese were to force certain things on them, they would
probably walk away," said Ken Dulaney, an analyst at Gartner
Inc.
-By Ben Charny, Dow Jones Newswires; 415-765-8230;
ben.charny@dowjones.com