UPDATE: Regulator: Fannie, Freddie Vulnerable To Delinquencies
October 08 2009 - 1:32PM
Dow Jones News
Fannie Mae (FNM) and Freddie Mac (FRE) remain vulnerable to
mounting home mortgage delinquencies as well as the troubled
multifamily market, the companies' regulator testified at a U.S.
Senate hearing Thursday.
"While a few positive signs of recovery in housing have begun to
emerge, we remain concerned and recognize the risk associated with
increasing numbers of seriously delinquent loans," Federal Housing
Finance Agency Acting Director Edward J. DeMarco told the Senate
Banking Committee in prepared remarks.
Government-sponsored enterprises Fannie and Freddie have racked
up a combined $165 billion in losses over the past eight quarters,
due to soaring mortgage defaults. The rate of seriously delinquent
mortgages at Fannie and Freddie is 4.2% and 3.1%, respectively,
according to DeMarco's testimony.
"These rates are disturbing both in their magnitude and the fact
that they continue to increase," he said.
Meanwhile, Fannie's and Freddie's combined share of the
multifamily or apartment market has swelled, jumping to 84% last
year from 34% in 2006, according to the testimony. The multifamily
sector is experiencing the highest vacancy rates since records
began in the 1950s.
The companies also remain vulnerable to losing senior staff as
the economy recovers, DeMarco said. In the past year, Fannie and
Freddie have both undergone substantial turnover at the highest
levels, and several key positions below the executive levels remain
vacant.
"As we see improvements in the economy, opportunities for
employees and officers to seek other employment will increase,
adding to the current retention challenge," DeMarco said.
The hearing is one of the first signs that lawmakers are turning
their attention to Fannie and Freddie, which were seized by the
government over a year ago amid soaring mortgage defaults.
In its plan to revamp financial industry regulation, the Obama
administration was silent on the issue of the government's role in
the housing market. It says it will unveil a proposal for the
future of Fannie and Freddie when it releases its 2011 budget in
February.
Since Fannie and Freddie were thrown into the conservatorship of
their regulator, they have been ordered to take on various
initiatives to prop up the housing market. Treasury has also pumped
$96 billion into the companies to keep them solvent under
agreements that give Treasury a preferred stake in the firms.
Treasury's agreements and the many initiatives the companies
have undertaken "could increase the costs and challenges of
associated with transitioning to new structures," William B. Shear,
Government Accountability Office director of Financial Markets and
Community Investment, said in prepared remarks. He said it was
impossible to predict the effects, but they could be
substantial.
Peter Wallison, a financial industry expert at the American
Enterprise Institute, said that proposals to revamp financial
industry rules could have unintended consequences for the mortgage
market.
He said proposals to require banks to hold more capital and to
retain a portion of the credit risk of any mortgages they sell to
investors wouldn't likely apply to Fannie and Freddie while they
remain in conservatorship. That would give the enterprises a huge
cost advantage that would allow them to expand their market share,
he said.
"If this happens they will likely assume the credit risk of the
entire mortgage system," Wallison said.
In his remarks, Shear reiterated many of the conclusions of a
recent GAP report on options for restructuring Fannie and
Freddie.
The companies' mixed record on achieving their housing mission
and their recent near collapse last fall reinforces "the need for
Congress and the executive branch to fundamentally reevaluate the
enterprises' roles, structures, and business activities in mortgage
finance," he argued.
- By Jessica Holzer, Dow Jones Newswires; 202-862-9228;
jessica.holzer@dowjones.com