UPDATE: Widening Comml Real Estate Crisis Hits US Banks
July 27 2009 - 5:21PM
Dow Jones News
When commercial real estate markets went bust two decades ago,
bankers said they learned a hard lesson.
The latest earnings reports from U.S. banks suggest many, in
fact, didn't.
Losses from loans tied to strip malls, office buildings, housing
complexes, and the like are hurtling toward record levels not seen
since the infamous savings-and-loan crisis.
But at some banks, according to the latest round of earnings
reports, the commercial real estate crisis has already arrived.
Those companies' worsening conditions could well foreshadow the
heavy losses at regional lenders in quarters to come - and failures
or takeovers for some.
"Commercial real estate in the United States of America is going
to get worse consistently over the next several quarters," said
Jamie Dimon, CEO of JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM), earlier this
month when he discussed his company's earnings.
At SunTrust Banks Inc. (STI), an Atlanta-based bank with 1,700
branches, nearly 20% of the company's $8.2 billion in commercial
loans tied to construction projects are nonperforming, or becoming
uncollectable, as of June 30. At the same time last year, 6% of
SunTrust's construction loans were in late-stage delinquency.
At KeyCorp. (KEY), a Cleveland-based regional bank with nearly a
thousand branch offices, nearly 11% of the company's $6.3 billion
in commercial construction loans were classified as nonperforming
in the second quarter. During last year's second quarter, 3% of
Key's construction loans were nonperforming.
At the height of the S&L crisis, which lasted into the early
1990s, late-stage delinquencies among commercial real estate loans
peaked at 6%, while slightly more than 2% of outstanding loan
balances became losses, according to data from RBC Capital
Markets.
In the last decade, KeyCorp expanded its commercial real estate
financing business beyond its 14-state footprint. SunTrust, like
Key, wrote loans in overheated markets and both have struggled in
recent quarters to stanch the flow of commercial real
estate-related losses.
KeyCorp and SunTrust both said they've been reducing their
exposures to commercial real estate. SunTrust said its commercial
loan portfolio is stabilizing.
At other firms, problems have started to appear more
recently.
Wells Fargo & Co. (WFC), for example, said 2.3% of its
commercial real estate mortgages were considered nonperforming as
of the second quarter, up nearly three-fold from 0.8% a year
ago.
The San Francisco bank purchased its large teetering rival
Wachovia Corp. at the end of last year, and Wells Fargo now holds
$138 billion in commercial real estate loans, more than any other
lender. Wachovia expanded aggressively into commercial real estate
before falling victim to rising losses from consumer loans.
Nearly a third of Wells Fargo's total commercial real estate
loans are tied to properties in California or Florida - two regions
among the hardest hit by the real estate depression.
Wells Fargo did not immediately respond to a request for
comment.
The other top commercial real estate lenders include Bank of
America Corp. (BAC), with $105.5 billion, and JPMorgan, with $67.6
billion, according to data from Standard and Poor's.
Should problems with commercial real estate loans keep
ballooning, bankers and analysts say the trend could force firms
now beset by losses to fall into competitors' arms.
Just Monday, Harleysville National Corp. (HNBC), a Pennsylvania
bank with 85 offices that's been rocked by real estate construction
loans, agreed to sell itself to Buffalo-based First Niagara
Financial Group Inc. (FNFG) for $237 million in stock.
Harleysville's recent struggles show how quickly commercial real
estate troubles can appear.
In April, homebuilder THP Properties, "a significant borrower"
of Harleysville National's, abruptly declared bankruptcy, the bank
disclosed in a filing. Until then, THP's loans had been considered
in good standing.
Twenty years ago, during the S&L crisis, defaulting
commercial property construction loans tagged thrifts with billions
in losses. Nearly 750 thrifts shut their doors or were sold under
pressure.
(Joe Bel Bruno contributed to this story)
-By Marshall Eckblad, Dow Jones Newswires; 212-416-2156;
marshall.eckblad@dowjones.com