- CHALLENGES FAIRFAX, AVANTE'S 19.99% SHAREHOLDER, TO DEMAND
SAME
- ASKS WHY FAIRFAX BLOCKED MARCH
2022 SALE VALUED AT $1.75/SHARE
- 1.1M OPTIONS GRANTED
APRIL 2022 AT $0.88 MUST BE RE-PRICED TO $1.75
- $600,000 FEE PAID TO KINGSDALE
ON BEHALF OF FAIRFAX AND CEO MOUNOUCHOS MUST BE REIMBURSED
- COSTS FROM BLOCKING SALE ESTIMATED AT $4.1M OR $0.15/SHARE
- EXCESS CASH OF $11M
($0.42/SHARE) SHOULD BE
DISTRIBUTED
- AVANTE SHOULD BE SOLD
TORONTO, April 25,
2023 /CNW/ - George Christopoulos today
announced the acquisition of additional Avante Logixx Inc.
("Avante") (TSXV: XX) shares and now controls 3,347,400,
representing 12.64% of Avante's shares. Fairfax (TSX: FFH) controls
5,297,434 shares or 19.99%.
Mr. Christopoulos also reiterates the disclosures made in the
Early Warning Report and Press Release dated March 29, 2023 filed on SEDAR.
Mr. Christopoulos continues to challenge both Avante's board
and Fairfax on:
- Sale valued at $1.75/share
blocked by Mounouchos and Fairfax in March
2022
Subsequently, a new four-person board was formed and
Mounouchos was appointed CEO/Chairman. Avante's shares have since
traded as low as $0.65.
- 1,100,000 options issued in April
2022 priced as low as $0.88
must be repriced at $1.75
Less than 30 days after blocking the sale valued at
$1.75 share, the board issued
1,100,000 options (including 800,000 to Mounouchos at an average
exercise price of $1.02). These
options must be repriced at $1.75.
Also, the board subsequently issued an additional 250,000 options,
priced at $0.80.
If 100,000 options are issued to each of the three newest
directors, option dilution from March
2022 would total 1,650,000, or 6.3%.
- Avante's payment of $600,000
obligation of Mounouchos and Fairfax must be reimbursed
Avante was not a party to the Mounouchos/ Fairfax
agreement with Kingsdale for "proxy- advisory services provided to
two large shareholders". Avante's decision to pay the $600,000 (plus HST) obligation of two of its
shareholders (Mounouchos and Fairfax) was entirely gratuitous, with
no benefit for Avante's other shareholders. Mounouchos and
Fairfax should repay $600,000
immediately.
- Costs from blocked sale estimated at $4.1m or about $.15/share
This includes the option grants, $600,000 proxy advisory fee, $750,000 break fee, estimated legal and
accounting costs, and CEO severance.
If Fairfax blocked the sale at $1.75/share because it believed intrinsic value
was materially higher – say, $2.00/share, then these costs imply Fairfax's
estimate of intrinsic value was at least $2.15/share. However, investment banker and legal
costs will be incurred to complete an eventual sale, perhaps
implying that Fairfax's estimate of intrinsic value was even
higher, at say $2.35.
Other significant governance concerns include:
- CEO and Chairman roles must be separated immediately
- Change in control and severance terms for CEO Mounouchos
should be limited
Avante should not enter into any agreement with
Mounouchos that provides a change in control payment or more than
statutory severance.
Mounouchos was paid severance of
approximately $600,000 in 2016,
following which he remained a director until 2017. Mounouchos
returned as an incorporated contractor in early 2018 and for the
four fiscal years ending March 31,
2022 was paid an average of $238,000 per year.
- Avante must adequately disclose its business strategy
including:
-
- whether it plans to expand to Florida and/or other jurisdictions
- its intentions concerning diversification into
cybersecurity.
Mounouchos has met at least three shareholders
and openly discussed Florida
acquisitions, and possible significant investments in a new area,
cybersecurity. Director Verner confirmed that Avante had considered
investing in Plurilock Security Inc.
Such investments would represent great risk
given Avante's poor long-term track record of creating shareholder
value, and lack of experience with Florida and cybersecurity. Such discussions
may also have constituted selective disclosure and could be a
reason why Avante's share price continued to experience downward
pressure, even well after March 2022,
when its sale at $1.75/share was
blocked.
- Board of Directors improperly appointed and does not
represent minority shareholders
Since March 30,
2022, Avante has added seven directors outside the normal
channel of a shareholder meeting, while failing to allow any
board representation for minority shareholders. The recent
re-appointment of Bruce Bronfman to
the board, without proper consideration of other candidates, is
disappointing. Bronfman served as a director from 2006 to 2018,
during which time little shareholder value was created.
Furthermore, he appears to have been recommended solely by CEO
Mounouchos.
At least one new independent board member
should be appointed, on suggestions by minority
shareholders.
- Board's independence is questionable
A four-person board of questionable independence
was responsible for the 1.1M options
granted on April 28, 2022 and the
$600,000 payment to Kingsdale:
-
- Leland Verner was previously a
director from 2007 to 2019, and during that time received
additional consulting fees of up to $100k annually.
- Wes Hall's Kingsdale was waiting
to receive its $600,000 fee for
"proxy-advisory services provided to two large shareholders" (i.e.,
Mounouchos and Fairfax), which was paid by Avante on June 3, 2022.
- There was no previous disclosure by Mounouchos and Fairfax
that they:
-
- expected to incur proxy related fees of $600,000
- would require Avante to pay the $600,000 to Kingsdale.
- Robert Klopot apparently made a
$200,000 loan to Mounouchos, which
was repaid in December 2022 by
Mounouchos' transfer of 200,000 Avante shares.
- Fairfax nominee, Wade Burton,
was added to the board July 18, 2022,
after the $600,000 payment to
Kingsdale.
- CFO Rotz resigned June 3,
2022, the same day $600,000
paid to Kingsdale
The timing implies the $600,000 payment was the reason for the CFO's
resignation. Avante waited until June
10th to announce the CFO had "provided notice of
his retirement".
- Re-appointment of founder Mounouchos as CEO and Chairman
despite Avante's poor performance since 2008
- Greater transparency required on compensation and related
party transactions:
-
-
- Mounouchos' current compensation not yet disclosed
and Avante appears to be remunerating its CEO through a
corporation
- Inappropriateness of providing Avante's directors with up to
$5,000 of services and doing so
without full disclosure
Unlike cash, the value and delivery of services can be
difficult to measure, monitor and control. Avante's "Related
Parties Transactions" notes to the financial statements have not
disclosed the value of services provided to its directors and
officers. Similarly, the value of services provided to significant
shareholders has not been disclosed.
- Settlement of employment contract dispute with former CEO
Campbell not disclosed
Avante apparently settled its employment
contract dispute with former CEO Campbell in January 2023, but has not disclosed the effect of
such settlement on its cash balance. Shareholders may not know if
there has been a resulting material change to Avante's
cash balance until the end of July
2023, when fiscal 2023 financial results are expected.
Campbell may have been seeking both severance as well as
compensation for the denied opportunity to realize $1.75 of value for his shares as well as his
share-based compensation.
- $11m of excess cash
($0.42/share) should be returned to
shareholders
Given Avante's history of poor investments and
destruction of shareholder value, excess cash should be returned to
shareholders, instead of making high risk acquisitions, in
unfamiliar territories and businesses.
Fairfax must demand Avante adopt best practices in
corporate governance, requiring:
- appropriate management
- separation of CEO and Chair roles
- clear disclosure of business strategy
- board representation for minority shareholders
- a policy of returning excess cash to shareholders where the
track record for deploying capital within the business and previous
diversifications has been poor.
In addition, Fairfax owes an explanation to other Avante
shareholders why it:
- blocked the sale of Avante valued at $1.75/share, which then resulted in approximately
$4.1m or $0.15/share of costs,
- acquiesced in the issuance of at least 1,350,000 stock
options priced as low as $0.80,
and
- had Avante pay the $600,000
obligation of Fairfax and Mounouchos.
Based on Avante's financial results and share price
performance since becoming public, Avante does not have appropriate
management and has been poorly governed. Often, the only means of
achieving Good Governance, and adequate returns for shareholders,
is to sell an underperforming company to new owners through a
controlled auction.
This press release includes the personal views and opinions of
George Christopoulos. It does not
and is not meant to constitute a solicitation of a proxy within the
meaning of applicable corporate and securities laws.
Avante's head office address is 1959 Leslie Street, Toronto, Ontario, M3B 2M3. A copy of this
press release may be obtained on Avante's SEDAR profile at
www.sedar.com.
SOURCE George Christopoulos