By Matt Andrejczak
SAN FRANCISCO (Dow Jones) -- A bruising battle for market share
that has rattled frozen food aisles for months shows no sign of
abating.
This is good news for cash-starved consumers eager to upgrade
from Salisbury steak. But it could crimp earnings at H.J. Heinz,
ConAgra Foods and Nestle S.A., top sellers of frozen entrees in the
U.S., if it goes on much longer.
Heinz, best known for its ketchup, makes Smart Ones, Boston
Market and TGI Friday frozen meals. ConAgra sells Healthy Choice,
Marie Callender and Banquet, while market leader Nestle owns Lean
Cuisine, Hot Pockets and Stouffer's.
Bill Johnson, chief executive at Heinz, said aggressive
promotions will squeeze industry margins and devalue the frozen
food category if they persist. So far, Heinz has resisted matching
the deep discounts of competitors even though this decision has
undercut sales.
While Heinz does not break out frozen food sales in its
financial statements, the company is the second-largest provider of
frozen prepared meals in the U.S. Smart Ones holds a 27% U.S.
share, Ore-Ida, 50%, and TGI Friday's, 17%, according to data the
company cites from researcher A.C. Nielsen.
"We expect to lose some share rather than chase volume to
achieve an end result that could be best described as profitless
prosperity," Johnson said at a recent analyst conference in Boca
Raton, Fla.
There were plenty of heavy promotions for frozen meals across
all categories during a recent trip to a Safeway store in San
Francisco.
In the health area, Smart Ones meals were fetching four for $11,
while a comparable Lean Cuisine meal was selling at three for $10.
Both normally go for $3.79 a piece. A larger Healthy Choice meal
was going for two for $7, below its $4.29 price.
In the restaurant category, Stouffer Home-Style Selects were
being offered at three for $10, under the $4.69 price, while Boston
Market Home Style Meals were being offered at two for $5, below the
$4.39 price.
Johnson plans to sit tight for now. He's seen this kind of
carnage before. In the mid-1990s, Heinz cut Weight Watchers prices
to pump up sales. It worked but at a steep price. Weight Watchers
went from being profitable to losing millions of dollars.
"Patience and prudence will be our strategy to a point," Johnson
remarked. He said Heinz (HNZ) may be forced to do something by
spring to sustain market share.
Food companies have long defended their turf for frozen ready
meals using price incentives.
Yet heightened price promotions are "due to the weaker economy
as companies seek to compete with not only each other but against
consumers cooking from scratch," Virginia Lee, senior research
analyst at Euromonitor International, wrote in an e-mail.
Frozen meals are important to ConAgra, making up 14% of the
company's total sales for the quarter ended Nov. 23. ConAgra (CAG)
has been offering food retailers special promotional deals to help
stave off a drop in demand.
"We have had to react somewhat to pricing discounts by
competitors. We have done this carefully so we can maintain the
margins we need to," spokeswoman Teresa Paulsen said.
Analysts say market-leader Nestle ignited the aggressive price
cuts last year after losing market share. They say the world's No.
1 food company, based in Switzerland, is probably taking advantage
of the decline of the euro against the dollar and the more
value-conscious mentality of U.S. consumers.
"Nestle is trying to get share back . . . they see a quick and
easy opportunity," said Ed Roesch, analyst at Soleil
Securities.
A spokesman for Nestle (NSRGY) declined to comment on the
company's pricing strategy. In its Feb. 19 earnings report, Nestle
said its frozen foods business has improved over the last six
months, notably in Hot Pockets.
The food giant has been promoting products that save families
money from eating out at restaurants like its 38-ounce Stouffer
Easy Express meals that can feed four for $7.39.
Given its gigantic stature in the food business, Nestle can make
its food at a lower cost than ConAgra or Heinz. This means it can
keep discounting as long as its profit margin holds and the U.S.
economy stays under duress.
"They will continue to push prices down. There is no incentive
for them to stop," said Frost & Sullivan research analyst Chris
Shanahan.
Frozen entrees have come a long way since the fish stick was
introduced during the household TV boom of the 1950s, and Lean
Cuisine and Weight Watchers were unveiled amid a diet craze in the
1960s. The food tastes better and it is healthier. Companies
highlight whole grain and fiber-rich ingredients as well as lower
sodium and cholesterol levels on the packages.
In the past year, Heinz and ConAgra have been pushing the
innovation button, a move that could help stabilize prices in the
frozen food aisle and protect their profits. The companies will try
to sell newer products at higher price points to counter heavy
discounting.
ConAgra has launched Healthy Choice Café Steamers and Marie
Callender's Signature Sautés. On the value side, ConAgra re-tooled
its Banquet meal line so they can sell for $1.
Heinz took the wraps off Ore-Ida Steam n' Mash potatoes and
expanded its TGI Friday Skillet Meals business, now approaching
$250 million in annual sales.
"It remains unclear how the frozen entree category as a whole
will eventually play out, considering Nestle's intent on taking up
market share," Deutsche Bank analyst Eric Katzman said in a
research note.
One thing is clear: There are better products on the shelf from
a decade ago.
Added Roesch: "We won't revert back to days when frozen foods
were treated like commodities and whoever gave the best promotion
got the volume."