Blue Square Announces it Received an Affirmation of Debentures Rating "ilA+" From Standard & Poor's Maalot With Outlook Revised
October 01 2009 - 11:50AM
PR Newswire (US)
ROSH HAAYIN, Israel, October 1 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- Blue
Square-Israel Ltd. (NYSE:BSI) (hereinafter: "Blue Square")
announced that it has received from Standard & Poor's Maalot a
report including affirmation of "ilA+" rating for the Debentures
issued by Blue Square on August 2003, while revising the outlook to
negative due to continued erosion of Company's financial ratios.
The official and binding report is in Hebrew. A translation of the
report to English is enclosed. Blue Square-Israel Ltd. is a leading
retailer in Israel. A pioneer of modern food retailing, in the
region. Blue Square currently operates 202 supermarkets under
different formats, each offering varying levels of services and
prices. For more information, please refer to the Blue
Square-Israel Ltd. website at http://www.bsi.co.il/. Forward
Looking Statements This press release contains forward-looking
statements within the meaning of safe harbor provisions of the U.S.
Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Forward-looking
statements may include, but are not limited to, plans or
projections about our business and our future revenues, expenses
and profitability. Forward-looking statements may be, but are not
necessarily, identified by the use of forward-looking terminology
such as "may," "anticipates," "estimates," "expects," "intends,"
"plans," "believes," and words and terms of similar substance.
Forward-looking statements involve known and unknown risks,
uncertainties and other factors that may cause actual events,
results, performance, circumstance and achievements to be
materially different from any future events, results, performance,
circumstance and achievements expressed or implied by such
forward-looking statements. These risks, uncertainties and other
factors include, but are not limited to, the following: our ability
to compete effectively against low-priced supermarkets and other
competitors; the effect of the recession in Israel on the sales in
our stores and on our profitability; quarterly fluctuations in our
operating results that may cause volatility of our ADS and share
price; risks associated with our dependence on a limited number of
key suppliers for products that we sell in our stores; the effect
of an increase in minimum wage in Israel on our operating results;
the effect of any actions taken by the Israeli Antitrust Authority
on our ability to execute our business strategy and on our
profitability; the effect of increases in oil, raw material and
product prices in recent years; the effects of damage to our
reputation or to the reputation to our store brands due to reports
in the media or otherwise; and other risks, uncertainties and
factors disclosed in our filings with the U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission, including, but not limited to, risks,
uncertainties and factors identified under the heading "Risk
Factors" in our Annual Report on Form 20-F for the year ended
December 31, 2008. You are cautioned not to place undue reliance on
these forward-looking statements, which speak only as of the date
of this press release. Except for our ongoing obligations to
disclose material information under the applicable securities laws,
we undertake no obligation to update the forward-looking
information contained in this press release. Blue Square Israel
Bond Rating 'ilA+' Affirmed; Outlook Revised To Negative On
Continued Erosion Of Company's Financial Ratios Primary Credit
Analyst: Tamar Stein Secondary Credit Analyst: Gadi Beeri Review -
The food retail sector in Israel is characterized, inter alia, by
increasing competition. Blue Square Israel has lost market share,
though it maintains a high competitive position. - The increasing
competition in the sector and the erosion in the company's
competitive position have led to a deterioration in financial
performance and in its weak debt coverage ratios. - We are
affirming the 'ilA+' rating on bonds (series A and B) issued by the
company, the second largest food retailer in Israel. - The revision
of the outlook to negative stems from uncertainty regarding the
company's continued financial performance and its failure to keep
its adjusted debt-to-EBITDA ratio below 4.5x. Rating Action On
October 1, 2009 Standard & Poor's Maalot affirmed the 'ilA+'
rating on bonds (series A and B) issued by Blue Square Israel Ltd.
We revised the outlook to negative from stable. Rationale
Increasing competition in the food retail sector in Israel,
particularly from the privately held companies, and the erosion in
Blue Square Israel's competitive position have led to a loss of the
company's market share and some erosion in its business position.
The company's profit margins remain low compared with those of its
local and international peers, although the launch of a
neighborhood store chain Mega B'Ir and a heavy discount chain Mega
Bool, together with a new home brand and a relaunch of the YOU
loyalty club, have led to a slight improvement in margins. In the
first six months of 2009 adjusted EBITDA-to-sales rose, slightly,
to 6.6% from 6.5% in 2008. We attribute the low profitability
mainly to the operating loss on Eden Teva and Dr. Baby stores. The
rating, however, is supported by the company's business profile,
viz. its position as the second largest food retailer in the local
market (~21% market share in the second quarter of 2009, according
to a Nielsen report) with wide geographic and business
diversification. The company benefits from the positive
characteristics of the food retail sector, which, by nature, is
more predictable and less exposed to demand fluctuations based on
the macroeconomic cycle. The rating of the bonds is negatively
affected by the company's financial position and erosion of its
financial ratios. The company suffered recently from a decline in
income, deterioration in company's operational flows, an increase
in leverage, and, as a result, a failure to keep the debt-to-EBITDA
ratio lower than 4.5x. In the first six months of 2009, this ratio
stood at 4.8x, compared with 4.7x in 2008. The company's adjusted
coverage ratios in the first six months of the year also continued
to deteriorate, although they remain consistent with the current
rating: FFO to debt stood at 15.8% while the EBITDA-to-interest
coverage ratio was 2x (compared with 16.3% and 2.3x, respectively,
in 2008). Despite the positive effect of the national holidays on
the group's activity in the second half of the year, we expect that
the current challenging environment will make it difficult for the
company to improve its financial position as required with the
current rating level. We expect the company to end 2009 with
negative free operating cash flow (FOCF), especially due to its
capex needs in new stores as well as an investment by its
subsidiary, Blue Square Properties Ltd. Liquidity We believe the
company's liquidity is consistent with its rating level. As of June
30, 2009, the company had cash and cash equivalents of NIS311
million and free cash flow from operating activities of NIS67
million. This compares with short-term debt of NIS330 million, half
of which was maturities on long-term loans. Payment of most bonds
begins in 2012. The company has another possibility of raising
sources in the short term due to the fact that most of its trade
receivables are by credit card. Blue Square Israel has good access
to banking sources though its belonging to the Alon Group-the
company is owned by Alon Israel Oil Company Ltd., rated ilA/Stable
by S&P Maalot[1]-somewhat restricts its access to local banks
due to the regulatory 'single borrower limitations'. We expect the
company to maintain a suitable level of surplus cash in the coming
quarters, which will support its debt payments and its current
operational needs, in light of the fact that no future considerable
increase is expected in capex needs, except for an investment by
its subsidiary Blue Square Properties, nor significant dividend
payment. Outlook The negative outlook reflects the continued
deterioration in the company's financial performance including the
increase in adjusted debt to EBITDA beyond 4.5x and the further
loss of market share. There is also uncertainty regarding an
improvement in the company's financial profile and coverage ratios.
Under the current rating we still expect the company to maintain an
adjusted debt to EBITDA ratio of less than 4.5x, although in light
of the company's current financial situation, we expect that this
will remain a serious challenge for the company. We could lower the
rating if leverage increases, affecting this ratio, if Blue Square
Israel loses further market share, if profit margins deteriorate
and/or if the company adopts an aggressive financial policy
(aggressive expansion, aggressive dividend payments) which could
impact on both the company's financial and business profile.
Revising the outlook to stable is unlikely for as long as there is
no improvement in the company's financial performance or if the
company fails to keep the adjusted debt to EBITDA ratio below 4.5x.
Related Research For further information on Standard & Poor's
criteria methodology, see our Criteria Methodology: Business
Risk/Financial Risk Matrix Expanded, which can be found at
http://www.maalot.co.il/matrix.pdf Ratings List Bond series Current
rating Former rating Series A ilA+/Negative ilA+/Stable Series B
ilA+/Negative ilA+/Stable Standard & Poor's Maalot ratings are
based on information received from the Company and from other
sources that Standard & Poor's Maalot believes to be reliable.
Standard & Poor's Maalot does not audit the information it
receives nor does it verify the correctness or completeness of such
information. It is hereby clarified that Standard & Poor's
Maalot rating does not reflect risks relating to and/or arising
from breaches, through intent or oversight, of any of the
obligations included in the bond documents and/or the incorrectness
or inaccuracy of any of the representations contained in the
documents relating to the bond offering that is the subject of this
rating, Standard & Poor's Maalot report or the facts that form
the basis for the opinions expressed to Standard & Poor's
Maalot as a condition for the giving of the rating, fraudulent or
dishonest acts of commission or omission, or any other act that
contravenes the law. The ratings could be revised as a result of
changes to the information received or for other reasons. The
rating should not be perceived as expressing any opinion concerning
the price of the securities on the primary or secondary market. The
rating should not be perceived as expressing any opinion concerning
the advisability of buying, selling or holding any security. (c)
Standard & Poor's Maalot reserves all rights. This summary is
not to be copied, photographed, distributed or used for any
commercial purpose without Standard & Poor's Maalot consent,
except to provide a copy of the whole report (with an
acknowledgement of its source) to potential investors in the bonds
that are the subject of this rating report for the purpose of their
reaching a decision concerning the acquisition of the aforesaid
bonds. [1] For more details on the parent company's rating see our
announcement on April 22, 2009 which is available on our website
http://www.maalot.co.il/. The company recently announced that
Africa Israel Trade and Agencies Ltd. had sold its holdings in
Alon. --------------------------------------- Contact: Blue
Square-Israel Ltd. Elli Levinson-Sela General Counsel &
Corporate Secretary Telephone: +972-3-9282670 Fax: +972-3-9282498
Email: DATASOURCE: Blue Square Israel Ltd CONTACT: Contact: Blue
Square-Israel Ltd., Elli Levinson-Sela, General Counsel Corporate
Secretary, Telephone: +972-3-9282670, Fax: +972-3-9282498, Email:
Copyright