WESTLAKE VILLAGE, Calif.,
April 30, 2015 /PRNewswire/ -- Gen
Z,[1] which comprises about one-fourth of the U.S. population, is
entering adulthood and creating new challenges and opportunities
for retail banks of all sizes to acquire them as customers, build
their loyalty and capture a larger share of wallet as they age;
however, banks will need to understand what drives satisfaction
among this generational group. Additionally, while overall
satisfaction has improved from 2014, satisfaction with mobile and
ATM features has slightly declined raising a red flag about retail
banks' approach to technology, according to the J.D. Power 2015
U.S. Retail Banking Satisfaction StudySM released
today.
The 10th annual customer satisfaction study is the
longest-running and most in-depth survey of the retail banking
industry, with more than 80,000 consumers evaluating various
aspects of their banking experience. The study measures
satisfaction in six factors (listed in alphabetical order): account
information; channel activities; facility; fees; problem
resolution; and product offerings. Channel activities include six
subfactors (listed in alphabetical order): ATM; branch; call
center; IVR; mobile; and website. Banks are ranked based on overall
customer satisfaction in each of the following regions:
California, Florida, Mid-Atlantic, Midwest, New England,
North Central, Northwest, South Central, Southeast, Southwest and
Texas. Satisfaction is measured on
a 1,000-point scale.
Gen Z and Retail Banking:
- Satisfaction among Gen Z customers (797) is higher than among
Gen Y and Gen X customers (781 and 778, respectively.)
Additionally, overall satisfaction among Gen Z customers of big
banks[2] (807) is higher than among Gen Z customers of regional
banks (796) and midsize banks (769).
- Among Gen Z customers, digital transactions are shifting from
website to mobile. A higher percentage of Gen Z customers use
mobile (38%) than the average use across all other generational
groups (19%), and Gen Z uses mobile more often than other
generations (48 times per year vs. 39 times).
- Surprisingly, branch usage among Gen Z customers is on par with
that of Gen X and Gen Y, as 76 percent of Gen Z customers have
visited a branch in the past 12 months, compared with 72 percent of
Gen Y customers and 74 percent of Gen X customers. Gen Z customers
who visit a branch average 12 times per year, compared with Gen Y
and Gen X who visit 11 times and 12 times, respectively.
- Among Gen Z customers, overall satisfaction is highest with big
banks, compared with regional and midsize banks, driven by
satisfaction in the facility and product offering factors, and the
ATM, branch, mobile and website subfactors.
- Despite lower satisfaction, midsize and regional banks are
capturing a greater share of Gen Z customers than they are with Gen
X. Among midsize and larger banks, 18 percent of Gen Z
customers indicate that their primary bank is a midsize bank,
compared to 13 percent for Gen Y. More than one-fourth
(28%) of Gen Z customers indicate their primary bank is regional
bank, compared to 24 percent for Gen Y.
- Satisfying Gen Z has a tremendous impact on advocacy. Highly
satisfied Gen Z customers (satisfaction scores of 800 and higher)
are five times more likely to say they "definitely will" recommend
their bank than those with medium or low satisfaction (scores below
800), who say the same (68% vs. 12%, respectively).
"It is not surprising that Gen Z is satisfied with website and
mobile at big banks, but they are also satisfied with the in-person
experience at big banks," said Jim
Miller, senior director of banking at J.D. Power. "There
is a common misconception that younger customers aren't using the
branch, but they use it about the same as Gen X and Y. Midsize and
regional banks risk losing the Gen Z customers to big banks if they
can't meet their needs regarding digital and in-person
interactions. There needs to be a seamless experience across all
channels. The first step for retail banks is to understand what is
important to Gen Z and what drives their satisfaction and
loyalty."
Overall Satisfaction Up, Mobile and ATM Satisfaction
Declines
Overall satisfaction with retail banks has improved to 790, an
increase of 5 points from 2014. The increase is largely due to an
increase in fee satisfaction and fewer customers experiencing a
problem or having a complaint. Fee satisfaction has increased by 15
points to 684 from 669, with few customers indicating a change to
their fees (9%) and only 14 percent of customers indicating they
paid a monthly service charge during the past 12 months. In 2015,
14 percent of customers have experienced a problem or had a
complaint, down from 16 percent in 2014 and 24 percent in 2010.
Among customers who do experience a problem in 2015, problem
resolution satisfaction has increased to 630, up by 10 points from
2014.
Mobile satisfaction, which has increased each year since the
sub-factor was included in the study in 2012, has declined by 3
points in 2015 to 837 from 840 in 2014. For big banks, this decline
is largely due to a 6-point drop in mobile scores year over year
(845 vs. 839, respectively), based on lower customer ratings in
clarity of information and ease of navigating.
- Despite increasing functionality offered in mobile,
satisfaction has dropped as fewer customers indicate that they
completely understand mobile (47% vs. 57% in 2014).
- Among customers who completely understand mobile, 46 percent
say they "definitely will not" switch banks, compared with the 34
percent of customers who partially understand mobile who say the
same.
- ATM satisfaction has declined by 6 points to 837 from 843 in
2014. ATM customer usage dropped to 65 percent from 70 percent in
2014 as use of cash has declined and the role of mobile as a
banking tool has increased. Although customers indicate having more
ATM features in 2015 than in 2014, they are less satisfied with the
range of services the ATM can perform and with ease of use of
ATMs.
"Satisfaction with mobile banking and ATMs is dropping as
customer expectations are outpacing technology improvements," said
Miller. "Customers expect to be able to perform more functions on
the same device this year than they did last year and that it will
be easier to use. Success will not be driven by just adding more
bells and whistles, but by balancing functionality with ease of use
and then clearly communicating features and benefits to
customers."
The study measures customer satisfaction with banks in 11
regions. Study results by region are:
California Region: Rabobank ranks highest in the
California region with a score of
816 and performs particularly well in the facility and channel
activities factors. Following Rabobank in the rankings are Chase
(800), and Bank of the West and Union Bank in a tie (798 each).
Florida Region: Chase ranks highest in the Florida region with a score of 834, performing
particularly well in the channel activities, facility and account
information factors. TD Bank (830) and PNC Bank (826) follow in the
rankings.
Mid-Atlantic Region: Susquehanna Bank ranks highest in
the region with a score of 834 and performs particularly well in
the channel activities, product offerings and account information
factors. Northwest Savings Bank (821) and S&T Bank (810) follow
in the rankings.
Midwest Region: First Midwest Bank ranks highest in the
region with a score of 818 and performs particularly well in the
product offerings, account information and channel activities
factors. Following First Midwest Bank in the rankings are PNC Bank
(808) and Commerce Bank (806).
New England Region: Bangor Savings Bank ranks highest in
the region with a score of 844 and performs particularly well in
the product offerings and fees factors. Rockland Trust Co. (840)
and Eastern Bank (805) follow in the rankings.
North Central Region: With a score of 835, Huntington
National Bank ranks highest in the region, performing particularly
well in the product offerings and fees factors. Following in the
rankings are 1st Source Bank (817) and Flagstar Bank
(816).
Northwest Region: Umpqua Bank ranks highest in the region
with a score of 809 and performs particularly well in the facility
factor. Wells Fargo (791) and
Columbia State Bank (787) follow in the rankings.
South Central Region: Arvest
Bank ranks highest in the region with a score of 859,
performing particularly well in the channel activities, product
offerings, facility, account information, fees factors. Following
in the rankings are Trustmark National Bank (844) and PNC Bank
(832).
Southeast Region: United Community Bank ranks highest in
the region with a score of 842 and performs particularly well in
the product offerings and facility factors. Following United
Community Bank in the rankings are First Citizens Bancorp (839) and
First Citizens Bancshares (832).
Southwest Region: With a score of 840, Arvest Bank ranks highest in the region,
performing particularly well in the product offerings, facility,
account information and fees factors. FirstBank (CO) (823) and
Chase (813) follow in the rankings.
Texas Region: Frost Bank ranks highest in the
Texas region with a score of 862,
and performs particularly well in the channel activities, product
offerings, facility, account information and fees factors.
Woodforest National Bank (826) and Regions Bank (820) follow in the
rankings.
The 2015 U.S. Retail Banking Satisfaction Study is based on
responses from more than 80,000 retail banking customers of more
than 130 of the largest banks in the
United States regarding their experiences with their retail
bank. The study was fielded quarterly from April 2014 to February
2015:
Wave 1: April 1, 2014 –
April 30, 2014
Wave 2: July 1, 2014 – August 4, 2014
Wave 3: October 1, 2014 –
November 4, 2014
Wave 4: January 5, 2015 –
February 2, 2015
Overall Customer
Satisfaction Index Rankings
|
(Based on a
1,000-point scale)
|
|
California
Region
|
|
Rabobank
|
816
|
Chase
|
800
|
Bank of the
West
|
798
|
Union Bank
|
798
|
BBVA Compass (Compass
Bank)
|
793
|
U.S. Bank
|
792
|
Wells
Fargo
|
787
|
California
Average
|
785
|
California Bank &
Trust
|
778
|
Citibank
|
775
|
Bank of
America
|
767
|
|
|
Florida
Region
|
|
Chase
|
834
|
TD Bank
|
830
|
PNC Bank
|
826
|
SunTrust
Bank
|
817
|
Regions
Bank
|
811
|
Fifth Third
Bank
|
810
|
Florida
Average
|
801
|
Branch Banking &
Trust (BB&T)
|
799
|
Wells
Fargo
|
798
|
Citibank
|
784
|
Bank of
America
|
783
|
|
|
Mid-Atlantic
Region
|
|
Susquehanna
Bank
|
834
|
Northwest Savings
Bank
|
821
|
S&T
Bank
|
810
|
Hudson City Savings
Bank
|
807
|
Branch Banking &
Trust (BB&T)
|
805
|
Community
Bank
|
801
|
Fulton
Bank
|
801
|
TD Bank
|
799
|
PNC Bank
|
798
|
Chase
|
796
|
Citizens
Bank
|
794
|
Huntington National
Bank
|
794
|
SunTrust
Bank
|
793
|
First NB of
Pennsylvania
|
792
|
First Commonwealth
Bank
|
791
|
NBT Bank
|
791
|
Manufacturers &
Traders Bank (M&T Bank)
|
790
|
National Penn
Bank
|
790
|
Capital
One
|
789
|
Wells
Fargo
|
785
|
Mid-Atlantic
Average
|
785
|
First Niagara
Bank
|
782
|
New York Community
Bank
|
779
|
Apple Bank for
Savings
|
776
|
Valley National
Bank
|
776
|
Citibank
|
775
|
KeyBank
|
771
|
Astoria
FS&LA
|
762
|
Bank of
America
|
758
|
Santander
Bank
|
752
|
HSBC
|
716
|
|
|
Midwest
Region
|
|
First Midwest
Bank
|
818
|
PNC Bank
|
808
|
Commerce
Bank
|
806
|
Chase
|
803
|
Regions
Bank
|
802
|
Great Southern
Bank
|
800
|
First Bank
(MO)
|
798
|
AnchorBank
|
795
|
Associated
Bank
|
794
|
UMB Bank
|
789
|
Bremer
Bank
|
786
|
MB Financial
Bank
|
786
|
U.S. Bank
|
785
|
Midwest
Average
|
785
|
Citibank
|
782
|
Bank of the
West
|
780
|
BMO Harris
Bank
|
774
|
Fifth Third
Bank
|
772
|
Wells
Fargo
|
771
|
Bank of
America
|
764
|
TCF National
Bank
|
749
|
|
|
New England
Region
|
|
Bangor Savings
Bank
|
844
|
Rockland Trust
Co
|
840
|
Eastern
Bank
|
805
|
TD Bank
|
800
|
Webster
Bank
|
795
|
Wells
Fargo
|
785
|
People's United
Bank
|
783
|
Citizens
Bank
|
779
|
Chase
|
774
|
New England
Average
|
771
|
First Niagara
Bank
|
763
|
Bank of
America
|
753
|
Santander
|
731
|
|
|
North Central
Region
|
|
Huntington National
Bank
|
835
|
1st Source
Bank
|
817
|
Flagstar
Bank
|
816
|
First Financial Bank
(OH)
|
814
|
City National Bank
(WV)
|
812
|
Chase
|
811
|
Regions
Bank
|
800
|
Wells
Fargo
|
800
|
Branch Banking &
Trust (BB&T)
|
799
|
WesBanco
Bank
|
799
|
North Central
Average
|
798
|
Charter
One
|
797
|
PNC Bank
|
797
|
Chemical
Bank
|
794
|
KeyBank
|
790
|
Comerica
Bank
|
787
|
Fifth Third
Bank
|
787
|
TCF National
Bank
|
781
|
U.S. Bank
|
780
|
FirstMerit
Bank
|
779
|
Bank of
America
|
775
|
Old National
Bank
|
771
|
BMO Harris
Bank
|
750
|
|
|
Northwest
Region
|
|
Umpqua
Bank
|
809
|
Wells
Fargo
|
791
|
Columbia State
Bank
|
787
|
Chase
|
786
|
KeyBank
|
780
|
U.S. Bank
|
779
|
Northwest
Average
|
778
|
Bank of
America
|
754
|
|
|
South Central
Region
|
|
Arvest
Bank
|
859
|
Trustmark National
Bank
|
844
|
PNC Bank
|
832
|
First Tennessee
Bank
|
823
|
SunTrust
Bank
|
820
|
BancorpSouth
Bank
|
812
|
Chase
|
812
|
South Central
Average
|
806
|
Regions
Bank
|
805
|
Capital
One
|
804
|
U.S. Bank
|
797
|
Wells
Fargo
|
792
|
Bank of
America
|
786
|
Branch Banking &
Trust (BB&T)
|
786
|
Whitney
Bank
|
786
|
BBVA Compass (Compass
Bank)
|
768
|
|
|
Southeast
Region
|
|
United Community
Bank
|
842
|
First Citizens
Bancorp
|
839
|
First Citizens
Bancshares
|
832
|
Branch Banking &
Trust (BB&T)
|
819
|
South State
Bank
|
819
|
PNC Bank
|
813
|
Synovus
Bank
|
813
|
Fifth Third
Bank
|
810
|
SunTrust
Bank
|
804
|
Regions
Bank
|
801
|
Southeast
Average
|
800
|
TD Bank
|
797
|
Wells
Fargo
|
797
|
Bank of
America
|
788
|
|
|
Southwest
Region
|
|
Arvest
Bank
|
840
|
FirstBank
(CO)
|
823
|
Chase
|
813
|
Bank of
Oklahoma
|
806
|
BancFirst
|
804
|
Wells
Fargo
|
798
|
Zions First National
Bank
|
795
|
Southwest
Average
|
795
|
U.S. Bank
|
785
|
Bank of the
West
|
777
|
BBVA Compass (Compass
Bank)
|
776
|
Bank of
America
|
769
|
Nevada State
Bank
|
762
|
|
|
Texas
Region
|
|
Frost Bank
|
862
|
Woodforest National
Bank
|
826
|
Regions
Bank
|
820
|
Amegy Bank
|
812
|
First Financial Bank
(TX)
|
812
|
Chase
|
811
|
Wells
Fargo
|
808
|
Texas
Average
|
804
|
Prosperity
Bank
|
797
|
Amegy Bank
|
812
|
Comerica
Bank
|
796
|
Capital
One
|
796
|
BBVA Compass (Compass
Bank)
|
794
|
Bank of
America
|
784
|
Citibank
|
782
|
International Bank of
Commerce
|
772
|
Media Relations Contacts
Jeff
Perlman; Brandware Public Relations; Woodland Hills, Calif.; 818-317-3070;
jperlman@brandwarepr.com
John Tews; J.D. Power; Troy, Mich.; 248-680-6218;
media.relations@jdpa.com
About J.D. Power and Advertising/Promotional Rules
http://www.jdpower.com/about-us/press-release-info
About McGraw Hill Financial www.mhfi.com
[1] J.D. Power defines generational groups as Pre-Boomers (born
before 1946); Boomers (1946-1964); Gen X (1965-1976); Gen Y
(1977-1994); Gen Z (born after 1995).
[2] Big banks are defined as the six largest financial
institutions based on total deposits as reported by the FDIC,
averaging $180 billion and above.
Regional banks are defined as those with between $180 billion and $33 billion in deposits. Midsize
banks are defined as those with between $33
billion and $2 billion in deposits.
Logo -
http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20130605/LA26502LOGO
To view the original version on PR Newswire,
visit:http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/gen-z-has-arrived-is-your-bank-ready-300074039.html
SOURCE J.D. Power