Jury Finds in Favor of Monsanto in Philadelphia Trial
September 11 2024 - 9:43PM
Business Wire
Young decision marks 14th favorable outcome in last 20 trials
for Company
Today, the jury reached a verdict in the Young Roundup™ product
liability trial before Judge Angelo Foglietta in the Philadelphia
Court of Common Pleas.
In response to the decision, Monsanto issued the following
statement:
“The jury’s verdict in favor of the Company marks the 14th
favorable outcome in the last 20 trials and validates the Company’s
strategy of taking cases to trial based on strong scientific and
regulatory evidence. The verdict makes clear that the plaintiff
failed to prove that Roundup™ was the cause of the injuries alleged
in this case, consistent with the scientific evidence and the
consensus of regulatory bodies and their scientific assessments
worldwide. While we have great sympathy for anyone who suffers a
loss or injury, the science proves that Roundup™ is not
carcinogenic.
“This verdict follows the favorable ruling from the Third
Circuit Court of Appeals in Schaffner v. Monsanto, which
unanimously held that the state-based failure-to-warn claims
central to these cases are expressly preempted by the federal law,
since the U.S. EPA has repeatedly concluded the product does not
cause cancer and approved the product label without any such
warning. The Company is actively taking steps to apply the
Schaffner ruling to other Roundup™ cases and looks forward to
presenting its arguments, as fully embraced by the Third Circuit,
at trial courts, appellate courts, and the U.S. Supreme Court.
“Additionally, outside the courtroom, we will continue
supporting legislation at the state and federal level alongside
hundreds of agricultural organizations to ensure that any pesticide
reviewed and registered by the U.S. EPA – and sold under a label
consistent with the EPA’s determinations – is sufficient to satisfy
requirements for health and safety warnings. Without legislative
certainty, the litigation industry will continue to target crop
protection tools that have been deemed safe by experts at the U.S.
EPA.
“We continue to stand fully behind the safety of Roundup™
products – critical tools that farmers rely on to produce
affordable food and feed the world.”
View source
version on businesswire.com: https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20240911893688/en/
Media Brian Leake Brian.Leake@Bayer.com (314) 370.3285